By Reid Zeising
When my son collapsed at home, nobody in our house stopped to ask which ambulance company was in our network. He was unconscious on the third floor with his front teeth knocked out. We called 911 and an ambulance came.
The bill was roughly $2,750. UnitedHealthcare paid about $950 and left us with close to $1,800 to cover out of pocket, because the ambulance that answered the call was out of network. I wrote about what happened shortly after, and I recently walked through it again on Scripps News. One question from the anchor has stayed with me. Are families supposed to hang up on 911 and keep calling until they find an ambulance that takes their plan?
Nobody would defend that answer out loud. But today’s rules warrant the question. This piece is written for the two groups who can change those rules: the lawmakers who write them and the insurers who apply them.
To Lawmakers: You Already Have the Blueprint
The No Surprises Act, which took effect in 2022, protects patients from most surprise out-of-network bills. Ground ambulances were left out. Congress created an advisory committee to study the problem instead, and that committee sent its recommendations to Congress and federal agencies in September 2024. Its central recommendation was simple: protect patients from balance billing for emergency ground ambulance transport.
The scale of the problem is well documented. A Peterson-KFF analysis found that 51% of emergency ambulance rides for privately insured patients included an out-of-network charge. Roughly 3 million privately insured people ride in a ground ambulance to the emergency room each year.
States have stepped in where Washington has not. Georgetown researchers writing for the Commonwealth Fund found that 22 states now offer some protection against surprise ground ambulance bills. Those laws help, but they have a ceiling. About 63% of privately insured workers are in self-funded employer plans that state insurance law does not reach. For most families, real protection has to come from Congress.
The groundwork is done and the recommendations are sitting on your desks. Extend the No Surprises Act to emergency ground ambulance transport, hold patient cost sharing to in-network levels and require that no bill reach a patient until the claim has gone through their insurance.
To Insurers: Look at the Incentives You Created
I appealed twice. Both appeals were denied. After the first denial, UnitedHealthcare offered to call the ambulance company and negotiate the bill on my behalf. Think about what that offer meant. They had already told me the balance was mine and that they carried no liability for it. They were negotiating a bill they would never pay. Surprise, surprise, the negotiation failed.
That gap in incentives runs through the entire claims process. KFF found that insurers offering HealthCare.gov plans denied 19% of in-network claims in 2024. Fewer than 1% of those denials were appealed, and insurers upheld 66% of the internal appeals they reviewed. The same pattern shows up in the claims Gain services, where nearly every claim is denied the first time it is submitted. A system built to deny first counts on most people giving up.
And the burden falls hardest on the sickest patients. A September KFF survey found that roughly half of insured adults ages 18 to 64 with three or more health conditions said their insurer denied or delayed care their doctor prescribed.
I understand the argument insurers make against state ambulance laws. When Colorado lawmakers unanimously passed a ground ambulance bill last year, the governor vetoed it over projected premium increases of 73 cents to $2.15 per member per month. UnitedHealthcare was one of the few groups registered against the bill. That premium impact is a real cost and it deserves an honest debate. It should be weighed against what families like mine are asked to absorb today, after an emergency in which nobody had a choice.
I have argued before that health insurers should be regulated more like utilities, allowed a fair profit and held to a standard of service. Emergency transport is the clearest test of that standard. Pay emergency ambulance claims at in-network cost sharing without a network test. Publish denial and overturn rates by service. When you tell a member a bill is theirs, stop offering to negotiate it as if you had a stake in the outcome.
Why This Matters Beyond My Family
Gain works with the providers and attorneys who care for injured people. An ambulance bill is often the first charge in a personal injury case, and an unpaid one can follow a patient for years as a balance, a collection account or a lien against a future settlement. Every surprise bill that Congress or an insurer could have prevented becomes someone else’s problem to resolve later.
After I spoke publicly, UnitedHealthcare reached out and asked to talk. We had that conversation, and it did not change the outcome. Most families never get a call at all. That is why we launched #GAINTheRightToCare, so people can share their own denials. If you are a lawmaker or a plan executive, those stories are worth your time.
This article was influenced by my recent interview on Scripps News. Watch it here: Health insurance isn’t enough: Many Americans still struggle with medical costs, survey finds.